DEERFIELD — The Zoning Board of Appeals approved a special permit Thursday night for Balance, a prospective garden and mindfulness center, pending a final review at the board’s next meeting.
Balance’s permit was put forward by Mary Clayton-Jones, who goes by Kate and is the prospective business owner, and is planned to be located at 477 Greenfield Road (Routes 5 and 10). The site is the location of the former Old Deerfield Garden Center.
Clayton-Jones said she does not currently own the property because she was waiting to see if the special permit would be granted first.
“I have a dream that this place could be a really amazing place to help elders,” Clayton-Jones said in her presentation to the ZBA. “A lot of people have felt uprooted and upheaved. … Seniors have been shut away and don’t know where they fit. What if I could create a place people could come to and sort of re-find or rediscover their roots?”
She said her plan for the business would be to help people, especially seniors, learn how to find balance in their lives through a walking garden, educational workshops, and sales of plants and other natural products designed to emphasize mindfulness.
Clayton-Jones said the site would require minimal landscaping work that would add native plantings to create a garden on the lawn.
“I like it as it is,” she said. “It certainly needs some work on the inside … but the idea is to keep the essence of the area right there.”
Landscape designer Kirtsten Baringer, of Ashfield-based Walter Cudnohufsky Associates Inc., said the plan is to raise only the foundation of the building and provide access to it through ramps or stairs.
Clayton-Jones presented plans for two 25-by-50-foot greenhouses and said an existing shed would be used as a “treatment room,” a term that ZBA member Bob Decker objected to because he said it could be misconstrued as a medical use, which is not allowed in the Residential Agricultural District.
“That’s a treatment room, and in my opinion, that’s medical,” Decker said. “I don’t think we should allow the treatment rooms.”
Clayton-Jones and other board members noted that the plans don’t include medical types of treatment, but rather holistic treatment such as providing posture advice or other sorts of non-medical help.
“What I understand is the semantics of the word ‘treatment,’” Clayton-Jones said.
ZBA member David Potter suggested the term be changed to “grounding room” or something along those lines, which Decker said he would be fine with.
“Eliminate those two words,” Decker said. “It can be just a room, don’t mention care or treatment.”
Beyond concerns over the “treatment rooms,” the ZBA saw no issues with the plan other than the Board of Health raising concerns about the septic system. In light of the Board of Health’s statement, ZBA Chair Adam Sokoloski suggested that a condition on the special permit be that the Board of Health needs to sign off on the septic before any work can be done.
Going through the rest of the town’s zoning criteria, the board determined traffic should not be an issue, especially if Clayton-Jones goes down the route of appointment-only visits.
“I don’t envision that on a Saturday afternoon it looks like Yankee Candle,” she said.
The ZBA also determined that the business would fit the character of the neighboring buildings and businesses on Routes 5 and 10.
Roger Sadoski, who said he was representing the Old Deerfield Country Store, said Clayton-Jones’ business would be a welcome addition to the neighborhood.
“I feel it’s a very positive thing for the community and the area,” he said.
The board voted 4-1 — with Bernie Sadoski the sole dissenting vote — to tentatively approve the special permit on the conditions that Clayton-Jones’ plans are approved by the Board of Health and the Conservation Commission, and that she must return to the ZBA in the case of a change of ownership or if there are any “substantive” changes to the plans as presented. The ZBA will reconvene at 6 p.m. on Tuesday, April 5, to go over the final details of the permit and sign it.
Clayton-Jones said if all goes accordingly, she plans to “start moving forward” with Balance in the fall. She added she will start the process of purchasing the property once the ZBA signs the permit.
Chris Larabee can be reached at clarabee@recorder.com or 413-930-4081.
