Allen Woods
ALLEN WOODS Credit: FILE PHOTO

In early 2017, Donald Trump came under investigation for his part in Russian interference in our elections. Reflecting on Attorney General Jeff Sessions recusing himself from the investigation, Trump longed for a familiar and malevolent presence: “Where’s my Roy Cohn?” he asked rhetorically, since Cohn died more than 30 years previously.

In the 1950s, Cohn successfully pushed for the execution of Ethel Rosenberg as a Russian spy even though Cohn and other prosecutors knew better. Later investigations showed that prosecutors threatened a key witness and encouraged his perjury to get her conviction and death sentence.

Soon after, Cohn oversaw the spectacular rise, and spectacular fall, of U.S. Sen. Joseph McCarthy while assisting in destroying the professional lives and reputations of thousands of government employees, teachers, actors, and others, without proof or due process. It was a media circus devoured by millions of Americans during a month of televised hearings.

Although McCarthy soon died in disgrace, Cohn landed on his feet and enjoyed a high-profile career defending the famous (George Steinbrenner, Andy Warhol) and infamous (members of all 5 New York crime families). He also formed a close bond with young Donald Trump, advising and protecting him by fighting allegations of racism in apartment rentals, preparing prenuptial agreements, and finding every corner to cut in the dense tangle of tax and regulatory codes.

The British newspaper The Guardian called him “a mentor in shamelessness,” a perfect description of Trump’s recent campaign appearances, describing sycophants willing to “kiss my a**” and admiring other male and female rear ends. But his overwhelming rejection by midterm voters has again sent Trump scurrying to find “my Roy Cohn.” This time, he may have found him: new White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller.

Cohn found success by vilifying alleged Communists; Miller has spewed hatred toward immigrants and supported white supremacists for years. He was raised in the “meme” age, and plays the media like a big bass drum, trolling opponents into apoplectic reactions with controversial, often authoritarian, quotations. He played the game even in high school, getting removed from a stage after complaining about reminders to pick up his own trash since there were “plenty of janitors” employed at the school to pick it up for him.

He has been neck-deep in many of the Trump administration’s unpopular actions and statements: separating immigrant children from their parents; Trump’s first inaugural address describing the “American carnage” he saw everywhere; immediately pronouncing Minneapolis nurse and murdered protester Alex Pretti an “assassin.” He recently stated that the United States is for “Americans and Americans only.” Miller, like Cohn, has risen to power by telling lies, always attacking, and never apologizing.

So where does “The Good Lie” come in? It’s a 2014 film about four young siblings surviving genocide and refugee camps, and their attempts to assimilate into American society. I found two strong lessons there after recently stumbling upon it.

First is the good a humanitarian government can create using its economic and moral support. Working with a United Nations committee, the administrations of Bill Clinton and George W. Bush supported a program similar in mission to the USAID ruthlessly cut by Elon Musk’s DOGE campaign. About 4,000 young civil war survivors from Sudan were welcomed into America and supported in their efforts to adapt to our culture. Although only a drop in the proverbial bucket, without it, those 4,000 would have been left to live in a refugee camp with few essentials (food, water, shelter) and little hope for the future.

But even more importantly, the film reinforces the power of familial love, even if the family is formed by common struggles rather than biology. In the end, one sibling makes a monumental sacrifice, reminiscent of O. Henry’s classic short story, “The Gift of the Magi,” in which two characters sacrifice possessions they cherish to offer the other a supreme gift.

The juxtaposition of two attitudes — the hateful ones of Cohn and Miller with the expansive, joyful ones in the film — makes the contrast as sharp as a razor. I hope the United States can again become a country of acceptance and support for people in America and foreign countries, one which banks on people’s best efforts and astounding resilience to fulfill the promise of the Statue of Liberty. I hope we can give thanks for our bounty and extend the open hand of opportunity to our own citizens and those around the world who have been cruelly neglected and abused.

Allen Woods is a freelance writer, author of the Revolutionary-era historical fiction novel “The Sword and Scabbard,” and Greenfield resident. His column appears regularly on a Saturday. Comments are welcome here or at awoods2846@gmail.com.