BRATTLEBORO, Vt. — Residents and officials told staff from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission recently that they questioned whether NorthStar Holdings had the financial wherewithal and technical expertise to successfully decommission the Vermont Yankee nuclear power plant.
Many Vernon residents turned out at Brattleboro Area Middle School to ask questions of NRC staff and voice their support for the sale of the closed Yankee plant to NorthStar, a large industrial demolition company based in New York City. They also spoke in support of an expedited cleanup of the site.
As resident Peggy Farabaugh put it, “Six years is better than 60 years.”
All Vernon residents who spoke Thursday night urged the NRC to approve the sale, to give the town hope for new economic life after Yankee’s closure in 2014.
Entergy Nuclear once employed more than 650 people at the site, and there are only 150 employees left, according to Michael Twomey, Entergy’s vice president of external affairs.
“Everyone in this room wants the same thing — this site to be cleaned up,” said anti-nuclear activist Betsy Williams of Westminster.
NorthStar plans on having the plant demolished and cleanup completed by 2026, decades ahead of Entergy’s original timetable of 60 years. And Northstar’s latest financial estimates said it can do the cleanup for $498 million — less than half of Entergy’s 2014 estimate of $1.2 billion.
Scott State, NorthStar’s chief executive officer, told the gathering his company can demolish and clean up Vermont Yankee with its current decommissioning trust fund, which is reported at $572 million.
State said NorthStar had done its own studies of the Yankee site and officials are confident there won’t be any “gotcha” moments.
Williams and other antinuclear activists said they had concerns about the new type of storage canister Entergy and NorthStar plan on using for the radioactive spent nuclear fuel remaining in Yankee’s spent-fuel pool.
Kate O’Connor of Brattleboro, chairwoman of the Vermont Nuclear Decommissioning Citizens Advisory Panel, which had invited the NRC to its meeting, asked the first question, one she said she had heard from many residents.
If decommissioning isn’t completed and the decommissioning trust fund runs out, “Who’s on the hook for the money?” if there’s a shortfall of funds, she said.
Andrea Kock, deputy director for the NRC’s division of decommissioning, said whoever holds the license is responsible.
Kock said NRC staff were still reviewing NorthStar’s request to transfer the Vermont Yankee license.
“We haven’t made any conclusions,” Kock told the gathering. She said the NRC staff’s job is to determine whether Northstar is financially and technically qualified.
“We won’t be able to give you a bottom line,” she said. “We aren’t at that point in the process. We haven’t drawn any conclusions.”
For every person who praised the sale from Entergy to NorthStar, there were questions and opposition to one of NorthStar’s main strategies for demolishing and cleaning up Vermont Yankee: “rubblization,” or mixing “clean” concrete waste — rubble from former buildings — with concrete contaminated with low-level radioactivity. The mixture would then be left on the site.
