My Nov. 4 column discussed a failure to communicate by Greenfield elected officials regarding a Tech school vote that will impact property taxpayers in 19 Franklin County communities for 30 years.
Greenfield officials decided not to sponsor any public conversation with taxpayers in advance of the vote. Nearly 89% of Greenfield voters stayed home. Some voters forgot Oct. 6 was an election — coming less than a month before the national midterms. There was no financial impact analysis from our city. The mayor and City Council president both expressed concerns over the impact on taxpayers, but no public strategy discussion was convened — until after the vote. Our city government slumbered.
Two recent major financial controversies convinced me that we should revisit our city charter’s budget management and change City Council elections:
- Greenfield voters on Oct. 6 rejected by 52.5% a proposal to construct a $56 million regional vocational school. I emailed the mayor and City Council to ask that “Greenfield educate its voters in advance of the vote.” Voters had to figure out the Tech school ballot question with no help from elected officials.
- Last June, the state Department of Revenue notified the city that it would not be certifying Greenfield’s free cash and sewer and water retained earnings due to cash reconciliation discrepancies. “There was a six-month period where a lot of things that should have been done were not being done,” the city’s Finance Director explained. An outside auditor was hired for $75,000 to reconcile the books. Some financial commitments had to be rescinded because of a lack of free cash certification.
From 1983 to 2003, Greenfield had a town manager. Norm Thideman served as our town manager from 1985 until 2002, when the town transitioned from a town manager-selectboard-town council to a mayor-town council government. In 2017, the town became a city with a mayor and City Council.
I supported our change to a mayoral form of government. I have also written several times that our City Council has no research staff of its own. Our council should put into motion a charter change study commission to consider a transition to a city manager/city auditor form of government, and make all 13 councilors at large so all voters get to vote for all councilors. We need competition in every precinct.
There are many models that combine a mayor with a professional city manager/auditor government. One recent example is Chapter 27 of the Acts of 2025, which created a new city charter for Cambridge. Under this model, the City Council elects from among its members a mayor and vice mayor. The mayor is the presiding officer of the City Council, but has no veto power, and has the same powers as any other City Council member.
The City Council appoints a city manager and a city auditor, who are appointed based on professional qualifications and experience. The city auditor keeps and has charge of the accounts of the city, and audits the accounts of all city departments, reporting to the City Council.
The city manager appoints — subject to City Council confirmation — all members of multiple-member bodies: Planning Board, Zoning Board of Appeals, Conservation Commission, etc. The City Council, through the city manager, requests department heads, chairs of a board, or city staff to provide information in relation to municipal services, functions, and powers.
The city manager is responsible for the implementation of policies established by the City Council: their resolutions, ordinances, appropriations, and loan authorizations. The city manager serves as its chief executive officer and is responsible for the administration of all departments, multiple-member boards, commissions, and officers of the city — except employees appointed by the City Council, School Committee, or officials appointed by the governor or elected officials. The City Council creates the employment agreement with the city manager for a term in office, and can add successive terms.
All residents want assurances that the city wisely spends every dollar it receives. We need a city government that provides professional staff experienced in municipal finance and management. None of the names I have heard whispered as running to be our next Greenfield mayor have executive or fiscal management expertise.
Taxpayers don’t want to be surprised by financial misreporting. Whether it’s full and timely notification of a major school building debt, or annual city expenditures — we need direct accountability for every dollar by a professional city manager. Our mayor and City Council have abetted a bored, disengaged electorate, where candidates run unopposed, where agendas are rarely explained, and where democracy is in a deep sleep.
Al Norman’s Pushback column is published in the Recorder every first and third Wednesday of the month.
