I do not reside in Turners Falls. Although I grew up in Greenfield, I no longer live in Franklin County. Therefore, some may say Turners Falls “Indian” mascot issue should not be my concern.. Perhaps. But the recent debate at my alma mater, Amherst College, which resulted in the elimination of “Lord Jeffrey” as a mascot, as well as similar efforts to remove other historical names from mention in other communities and academic institutions, makes this issue one that needs careful attention.
First of all, I do not favor removal of the Indian as a mascot at Turners Falls or anywhere else. By naming the school, athletic teams, organizations, etc, the “Indians,” Native Americans are not defamed or seen in a negative context — at all. I lived in Medfield for 28 years and our school mascot, for my kids’ teams, was the Warriors. The titles simply recognize the Native Americans and, by trying to win and perform well, it actually honors them. Conversely, I have always considered the Washington “Redskins” name offensive and the organization that should seek another name. Color of skin differs from the group itself.
Historical revisionism can be both convenient and dangerous. We can discuss whether certain conduct would be acceptable today, but it is problematic and counterproductive to impose our standards retroactively on actions taken 300 years ago. The result of doing so has been a backlash in many parts of the country that undoubtedly fuels some of the fires for a national candidate who otherwise — probably wouldn’t — and shouldn’t be running for the highest office in the land.
This is a question of ethics, pragmatism and common sense. The Turners Falls students have honored the “Indians” name for years in their pursuit of achievement. It makes sense, for once , to invoke one the all time best messages in a song we all know and appreciate when deciding whether to eliminate the name “Indians.”
Let it be.
Steve Kramer
Mashpee