In the early 1970s, I worked as an instructional assistant at a facility where the children lived upstairs and were educated downstairs, and the only thing that the students had in common was that they did not fit in at home, in classrooms or in the community. Schools didn’t want to teach them or didn’t know how to teach them, families and communities couldn’t handle them, and they had to go somewhere, so they ended up in institutions like the one in which I was working.
My work with these children was eye-opening to me, partly because I had not been around students with special needs in my own K-12 education. There were always kids who did not learn as quickly as others, but I don’t remember children with physical disabilities or with significant learning challenges that would make them eligible for special services today.
When I had my own classroom in the early 1980s, up to one-quarter of my students had disabilities, and later, when I was supervising student teachers in several classrooms, the number of students with special needs rose to close to 40% in some classrooms.
Where were these children when I was in school, in the 1950s and early ’60s? I know now that they were mostly excluded from public education by legal and illegal segregation, and by communities shaped by the eugenics ideology that defined who was intelligent, as well as who belonged and who didn’t because they were different.
This month’s column offers a brief overview of how we have or have not educated children with special needs through our history.
Before 1800
Before 1800, children with what we would now refer to as special needs were seen by some preachers and communities as evidence that their parents were somehow unholy, if not downright sinners. Many families kept their children out of sight so that the community would not judge them, and they were not part of any public education system. This was during the time of the Old Deluder Satan Act of 1647, which said that every town of 50 or more must have a school and children taught to read the Bible to protect them from Satan.
After 1800
Attitudes began to change around 1800 as medical and scientific knowledge led to the possibility of addressing and treating disabilities.
Most of the focus initially was on physical disabilities. Gallaudet University was the first school for students who were deaf or hard of hearing. Samuel Gridley Howe began working with students who were blind and founded the Perkins School for the Blind in the 1830s, and this work encouraged research into other areas of disability.
Still, these were largely private efforts; there were still few public schools that accepted students with disabilities, virtually no community resources or support for people with disabilities, and little attention paid to those with cognitive or psychological disabilities.
Compulsory schooling
Massachusetts passed the nation’s first law requiring that students attend school in 1852. Children with special needs were excluded from this law so that schools could legally reject them; in fact, many states and towns enacted specific laws barring them from public education.
The Civil War, eugenics and disabilities
Around the beginning of the Civil War, there was a growing movement linking race and genetics to intelligence that eventually morphed into the eugenics movement.
For eugenicists, society’s problems — such as crime, mental illness, alcoholism, poverty and disease — came from genetics, which were inherited, fixed and unchangeable. They believed that educating those with inferior genes was pointless as they could not learn.
Eugenicists believed they could improve society by identifying those with good genes and encouraging them to have more children while keeping those with “inferior” genes (especially people of color and those with disabilities) from having more children. As the eugenicist ideology gained favor among decision makers, they enacted policies of segregation, exclusion and the forced sterilization of more than 70,000 people. This left little or no room for those who learned differently, looked different or behaved differently.
The eugenics movement began to fall out of favor in the U.S. after World War II, as the role it played in German atrocities became public knowledge. Though this did not result in immediate change in policies in the U.S., the ideology began to be challenged here.
The path to special education in schools
The first major legal step toward truly serving students with special needs began with the Brown v. Board of Education decision of 1954. We think of this U.S. Supreme Court decision primarily in terms of ending racial segregation, but it also opened the door to several legal decisions that improved rights for those with disabilities, and led to the IDEA and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which form the basis for disability rights today.
The most significant legal advance in respecting and serving students with disabilities came in 1975 with the Education for All Handicapped Children Act. The law was updated in 1990 and is now known as the IDEA. This act mandates that schools ensure “free and appropriate public education” for students with disabilities in the “least restrictive environment,” which means that they should be included in mainstream classrooms, with necessary support, or included as much as possible in the school community.
Under the IDEA, parents are required to be part of the decision-making process in a child’s education. The school is responsible for developing a specific learning plan for that student called an Individualized Education Program (IEP) that identifies specific learning goals, the ways in which those goals will be met and ways to assess whether the plan is working. It also identifies what accommodations the child is eligible for, which will enable them to get the education they are entitled to by the IDEA.
Meanwhile, the ADA of 1990 “prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability just as other civil rights laws prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, color, sex, national origin, age and religion. The ADA guarantees that people with disabilities have the same opportunities as everyone else to enjoy employment opportunities, purchase goods and services, and participate in state and local government programs.” The goal of the ADA is to guarantee “equality of opportunity, full participation, independent living and economic self-sufficiency to persons with disabilities.”
Special education today
There are 13 categories included within the special education umbrella, each of which is unique, so a special ed department needs to meet the unique needs of each of the students determined to be eligible for services. Truly serving the wide array of students in special education is an incredibly complicated challenge that schools have the legal, ethical and moral responsibility to meet. However, school districts are struggling to meet those responsibilities while lacking the funds, the staff, the resources and the support to do so. I will discuss the current state of special education more in a future column.
Doug Selwyn taught at K-12 public schools from 1985 until 2000, and then at university as a professor of education until he retired in 2017. He is the chair of the Franklin County Continuing the Political Revolution education task force. Reach him at dougselwyn12@gmail.com.
