SUNDERLAND — After more than a year and a half of public hearings on a proposed 9,100-square-foot Dollar General building at the corner of Route 116 and Clark Mountain Road, the Zoning Board of Appeals voted unanimously on Wednesday to deny the special permit.

“I was very proud of the board, the way we worked here,” ZBA Chair Steve Krol said after the vote. “At the very first hearing, I mentioned to the applicant I was obliged to provide a fair, open hearing on their application and I think we did. We strived to do that.”

The draft of the board’s decision, which will likely be revised and finalized by the Dec. 2 deadline required under Massachusetts General Laws, states that the ZBA found that “granting the application will have adverse effects [that] overbalance its beneficial effects on the neighborhood or town.”

According to the town’s bylaws, when reviewing special permits, the ZBA must consider whether the “adverse effects” outweigh the “beneficial effects” in eight categories. The criteria include the social, economic or community needs the proposal serves; traffic flow and safety; adequacy of utilities and other public services; neighborhood character and social structures; qualities of the natural environment; potential fiscal impact; the impact on drainage, stormwater management or drinking water recharge areas; and the impact on public safety and municipal services.

When voting to deny the special permit, ZBA member Hollis Graves noted the social, economic or community needs category was a factor in his decision.

The board’s draft decision states the proposal “would not serve an economic or community need in a rural community such as Sunderland,” and the board “does not find there to be a community need for a large retail store” in town. It goes on to say that the applicant has not explained how “a large retail store served an economic or community need.”

The draft decision also mentions that the ZBA only heard “an outpouring of community opposition” against the proposed store and no comments in support of it. In addition, the draft states that the proposed store would negatively impact the neighborhood character and social structure.

“The board recognizes that the project is located in a commercial district along a state highway, and thus, the area does not have significant neighborhood character as is,” the draft decision notes. “However, given the scaling and scope of nearby businesses, the board finds that the proposed 9,100-square-foot retail store is out of place in the otherwise small-scale commercial uses nearby, and that the building will dwarf other buildings in the area and across town.”

At prior hearings, several local business owners claimed a Dollar General would drive customers away from their small businesses and, as a result, hurt the local economy and the town’s sense of community.

ZBA member Stuart Beckley said his decision was “particularly based” on the proposal’s impact on traffic flow and safety, a topic that sparked discussion at several hearings. The draft decision claims the proposed store’s location and “full access driveway” will drive up “vehicle conflicts in an unacceptable manner to the board.”

At a March public hearing, Michael Wulforst of Bowman Consulting Group had said the applicant’s traffic study projected the change would not impact traffic levels on Route 116, based on data collected during the “peak hours” of 7:45 to 8:45 a.m. and 4 to 5 p.m. over a Wednesday and Thursday. Although Tighe & Bond’s peer review of the applicant’s traffic study found that the data was consistent with the Massachusetts Department of Transportation’s (MassDOT) traffic counts, many residents stressed that the applicant’s data contradicted their lived experiences with traffic along Route 116, with Krol claiming it “doesn’t match the eye test.”

Besides the “adverse effects” related to the categories listed in the town bylaws, the ZBA’s draft decision mentions that the proposed design for the store does not comply with the town’s requirements for driveway separations — a topic that is the source of a lawsuit that Michael Pill, the attorney representing the applicant, Calito Development Group, filed against the town in October.

The lawsuit, a Land Court petition, stems from a disagreement between Pill and town counsel Michael D’Ortenzio over whether the site of the proposed store consists of one parcel or two. While D’Ortenzio believes an Approval Not Required (ANR) plan that the Planning Board endorsed in 2014 effectively splits the property, Pill has said it lacks validity without a recording in the Registry of Deeds. The only access point the ZBA had identified for a driveway for the proposed Dollar General was a 21-foot-wide space located between these two parcels.

During the Sept. 3 hearing, D’Ortenzio said the attorneys are looking at case law “pointing in opposite directions.”

According to D’Ortenzio, the judge decided to wait to make a determination until after the ZBA issues a finalized decision on the special permit by Dec. 2.

Over the phone on Thursday, Pill said he plans to appeal the ZBA’s denial of the special permit. He claimed the public hearing process was unfair, and the board members “made up their minds a long time ago” and were “looking for every reason” to deny the special permit.

From the traffic study peer review to the peer review for the stormwater and drainage report, Pill said, “We spent a fortune dealing with every issue.”

He claimed that the ZBA members and residents who encouraged the board to deny the special permit are “shooting the town in the foot,” and Sunderland residents will have to travel to Greenfield, Northampton or Hadley for a grocery store.

“They’re basically knifing what is in the best interest of all the residents of Sunderland,” Pill said.

Aalianna Marietta is the South County reporter. She is a graduate of UMass Amherst and was a journalism intern at the Recorder while in school. She can be reached at amarietta@recorder.com or 413-930-4081.