We write with deep concern over the Mohawk Trail and Hawlemont school committees’ plan to close all four elementary schools in the Mohawk Trail and Hawlemont Regional School Districts, cut 65 jobs, take on tens of millions of dollars of debt for a single K-12 campus, and extend school bus commutes to almost two hours per day.
While we are keenly aware of the fiscal crisis facing our public schools and the impossibility of continuing to raise property taxes to make up for flat state aid, shutting our schools down is not the answer — and we are not alone in this position. One hundred and sixteen citizens recently signed an open letter, similar to this one, addressed to the members of the Ashfield, Buckland, Charlemont, Colrain, Hawley, Heath, Shelburne, and Plainfield selectboards and finance committees. You can find that letter at the Our Schools, Our Towns website, https://www.osot-info.org/.
Over the past few years, the Mohawk Trail School Committee has hired six private consultants for a “Sustainability Study,” brought in almost $650,000 of state funds and anonymous private donations to pay those consultants, and convened countless hours of public meetings, all to convince us that there is no hope for our elementary schools.
We believe there is a better way forward, but it involves turning our full attention — as a community and as a district — to advocating for the funding we deserve.
Some points to consider:
- Massachusetts is awash in cash for education, thanks in part to the Fair Share amendment, which taxes incomes above $1 million. In the three years since its passage, it has raised almost $9 billion — more than double what the state had expected. Thanks to a constitutional amendment, this money can only be spent on education and public transportation.
- The state has increased funding for education substantially, including raising per-student aid to $160, the highest ever — and then has proposed adding an extra $112 per student, committing $20 million to rural aid (compared to only $12 million last year), increasing transportation funding by $7.2 million, setting aside even more for special education, English language learners, etc.
- The state has established a commission to overhaul the formula governing how public schools are funded, because it isn’t working anywhere.
- The district’s pre-K programs are full to capacity — Ashfield’s community preschool even has a waitlist, which means that we have a large pulse of students just about ready to enter our elementary schools.
- Elementary enrollment in our district has been holding more or less steady for about a decade.
- We are seeing a once-in-a-generation turnover of housing coming on the market, perfect for young families looking for intimate schools in a beautiful setting with dedicated staff and teachers.
- A new state commission is studying the formula for payment in lieu of taxes (PILOT). PILOT agreements help communities recoup lost revenue that is a result of state property tax exemptions, but they are woefully inadequate, and there is broad agreement that the formula needs updating.
This is the time for each of us to do everything we can to support our schools, our teachers, and our students so that they can thrive. It is not the time to sell them short. Imagine what our schools could be if the School Committee dedicated the same resources they’ve spent on closures and job cuts to thriving schools. Imagine what three years’ worth of studies and community presentations, $650,000 spent on community organizers and state-level advocacy, partnerships with teachers and parents, and marketing materials that sing our schools’ praises widely and loudly could accomplish.
By the end of March 2027, the School Committee will bring a vote before the eight towns in the district, asking us all to appropriate the full cost for the preliminary study the state requires to fund a new campus. The school committees estimate that this study will cost $1.2 million.
We say no more money for job cuts and school closures. Please visit https://www.osot-info.org/ for the 116 signatories who want to keep our schools open.
Luann Lord lives in Buckland, finn phoenix in Ashfield and David Greenberg in Colrain.
