GREENFIELD — Residents involved in agriculture had the chance to share their perspectives on the broad issues affecting farmers during a Franklin County Agricultural Commission Roundtable Meeting on Saturday.

Sarah Gardner and Pete Westover of Conservation Works have led several of these roundtables. The event, held at the Terrazza restaurant, was also attended by state Sen. Jo Comerford, D-Northampton, who shared the work going on in state government to help farmers, and the need for continued and increased focus on agriculture.

“The thing I think that’s incredibly cool about what is happening today and across the commonwealth is that the Legislature and advocacy organizations statewide are focusing more and more on the well-being of farms and food producers,” Comerford said, “but it’s still not enough because it’s still too hard to farm. It is still too hard to produce food, both economically and in terms of long- and short-term sustainability. Organizing, getting collective voices and sharpening priorities is really the only way.”

Comerford thanked the continued work and advocacy of the Massachusetts Department of Agricultural Resources (MDAR), the Massachusetts Food System Collaborative, the Massachusetts Farm Bureau Federation and the Massachusetts Food System Caucus as state entities working to “make it easier to farm and produce food.”

Westover and Gardner emphasized the more localized role of agricultural commissions during their presentation. Agricultural commissions are advisory committees that represent farmers and can be formed by any municipality in Massachusetts, as laid out in Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40, Section 8L.

Westover emphasized the importance of having an agricultural commission to provide input to a town government.

“What we really hope is that ag comms can be right in the center of any discussion a town has about farmland, or land in general,” Westover said. “The question should come up at Town Meeting: ‘Here’s a warrant article relating to land. Well, what does the Ag Comm recommend?’ They ask the Finance Committee; they ask everybody else. … [Agricultural commissions] are not one of the four boards legally required to be notified, but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be consulted.”

During his presentation, Westover outlined tips for members of agricultural commissions to build a strong board. Among other things, Westover emphasized the need for a “spearhead person” to lead the board’s efforts; having a variety of members of different ages and agricultural experience; forming good relations with the other town boards; having thorough knowledge of Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40, Section 8L; having plans for funding farmland protection; and having knowledge of all the farms in town.

According to Gardner, agricultural commissions are important, not only for the promotion and representation of agriculture, but also to help mediate local disputes. Gardner also mentioned how having a strong agricultural commission can help newcomers to western Massachusetts understand the culture of a farming community. 

“There are a lot of disputes coming up with new people moving into rural communities that are agricultural communities, who don’t fully appreciate the impacts of agriculture,” Gardner explained, “but most towns and rural areas in the state have passed right-to-farm bylaws, which protect any normal farm from new nuisance suits. … With all the demographic transition going on, it’s becoming a big issue.”

Gardner also encouraged towns to have a strong agricultural commission because, as Massachusetts has fewer and fewer farmers, agricultural commissions are needed to keep agriculture protected and visible.

“[Agricultural commissions] help raise awareness so people know that farmers are there. It will help newcomers make the connection. You know, newcomers are usually really into buying local food or going to the farmers market,” Gardner said, “but they have to understand the connection to the manure that was spread on that field, that’s creating fertility in that field and creating good hay to feed the cow, that is what is making your local hamburger.”

A large point throughout Saturday’s roundtable from many perspectives was the need to make an agricultural vocation economically sustainable. Gardner encourages those who are not involved in agriculture directly to buy directly from farms as much as possible, and to pay attention to political and conservation issues that concern farmers.

Another option discussed was the role that land trusts can play to help farmers economically. Liam Cregan, of Franklin Land Trust, reminded attendees that selling land to be protected by a land trust is one way to help relieve farmers economically.

Another type of land conservation that was discussed was Agricultural Preservation Restrictions, or APRs. APRs allow a farmer to sell the development rights of their property to the state or a private land trust, while retaining ownership of the farm, effectively permanently allocating the land for agricultural use.

While APRs may have an economic incentive, Norman Davenport, who runs the Davenport Maple Farm in Shelburne and had to give up full-time dairy production in 2018, said that the money from an APR can only go so far when the economic situation for farmers is so severe. Davenport’s farm has been under an APR for 40 years.

Davenport did not want anyone at the roundtable to forget that farmers need to make ends meet, and conservation won’t help if agriculture is economically unfeasible.

“The APR program was created because of the destruction of economic sustainability,” Davenport said. “Its present success is because of the destruction of economic sustainability, and its future success depends on the destruction of economic sustainability. If the farm was never meant to survive, then who’d you save the land for?”