Editor’s note: As part of the Greenfield Recorder’s end-of-the-year features, we are publishing in two parts our choices for the top 10 new stories of 2022. They are listed in no particular order.
The aftermath of the May 6 verdict that found the Greenfield Police Department and Police Chief Robert Haigh Jr. racially discriminated against a former officer — a decision that continues to reverberate among the city’s residents and officials — will bleed into 2023 with the official notice of appeal filed last week.
The verdict, delivered by a special jury in Hampshire County Superior Court, found Haigh had racially discriminated against former Officer Patrick Buchanan, who is Black, when he denied him a promotion in 2014, which the jury found was due to “racial animus.” Buchanan was the only Black officer on the force at the time, according to his civil complaint and the city’s answer to the complaint.
In 2015, Buchanan was promoted to provisional sergeant but was soon placed on paid leave following a complaint from a fellow officer. After an internal investigation, Buchanan was placed on a three-day unpaid suspension and demoted from his post.
Then in late 2020, Greenfield announced three openings for promotion to sergeant, in which 10 officers applied for the promotion. During this process, Haigh allegedly scored Buchanan so low to “ensure that Buchanan had an overall ranking of fifth and as such was not in contention” for the position, according to the lawsuit. The Superior Court jury subsequently found Buchanan had been “discriminated against or retaliated against” in connection with the sergeant promotional process.
After the verdict, Haigh and Lt. Todd Dodge were both placed on paid administrative leave over an April 22 conversation in the court parking lot, which Haigh interpreted as an attempt to circumvent court proceedings regarding a possible settlement, according to a city investigation.
The ruling also roiled Greenfield residents, who protested outside of City Hall and have dedicated long periods of public comment at City Council meetings to express their frustration with the way the situation has played out.
Haigh and Dodge were both reinstated and the city filed its appeal of the decision on Dec. 20. The appeals process, according to city attorney Leonard Kesten, could take one or two years.
—Chris Larabee
Library renovations and expansions were on the minds of voters in Deerfield, Orange and Shutesbury this year, as projects came to the floor of Town Meeting, then the ballot box. Residents approved Deerfield and Shutesbury’s projects, but voters in Orange shot down Wheeler Memorial Library’s proposed project.
Shutesbury’s M.N. Spear Memorial Library was the first project brought before voters, who approved spending nearly $1.3 million and borrowing up to $1.17 million at May’s Annual Town Meeting to replace the century-old library with a 5,490-square-foot facility on Leverett Road. Residents solidified their support for a new library in June by approving a debt-exclusion override. Shutesbury was selected for the statewide Small Library Pilot Project, meaning the town has to cover a quarter of eligible costs and all ineligible costs. In all, the project has an estimated cost of $6.4 million.
Deerfield’s residents approved Tilton Library’s expansion project this year, once at Special Town Meeting in October, then again at a debt-exclusion vote in December. Voters approved appropriating $12.3 million in total, with an expected borrowing amount of $5.26 million to $6.26 million. The library could potentially break ground in the fall.
In Orange, however, residents turned down a debt-exclusion override by 58 votes in November’s general election. The ballot measure would have authorized the town to borrow up to $10.4 million to supplement a $5.2 million state grant to renovate the Wheeler Memorial Library.
With borrowing denied, the library applied for and received an extension to its Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners (MBLC) grant deadline, which was set to expire on Jan. 9. The new deadline for Orange to match the funds is April 30, according to Library Director Jessica Magelaner.
With the extended deadline, Magelaner said she hopes the state comes through with extra American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding, which may come through an appeal — spearheaded by Deerfield’s Selectboard — to the governor’s office requesting ARPA money for library projects around the state.
“The plan for January is to try to connect with the new Healey-Driscoll team,” Magelaner said. “We’ll be meeting weekly with other directors to really push our case for the ARPA funding.”
—Chris Larabee
City Council slashes $425K from police budget
City Council approved a $425,000 cut to the Greenfield Police Department budget in May, a cut meant to signal that “major change” was needed in the city’s police force.
The cuts, which included $400,000 for salaries and $25,000 in expenses, came in response to a jury verdict in April that found Haigh and the Police Department had racially discriminated against Buchanan when he was denied a promotion in 2014, and then again during a promotional process in late 2020.
Initially, the cuts were expected to mean a significant reduction in force, with as many as eight of the most recently hired officers to be laid off. However, then-Acting Police Chief William Gordon proposed a plan that did not include layoffs, but rather a reduction of cruisers on the road that paired two officers each in two cruisers (a response to skyrocketing fuel prices), the elimination of summer bicycle patrols and placing detectives on a hybrid schedule. Additionally, positions that opened, or were soon-to-be-opened, would remain unfilled. At least one senior officer, Laura Gordon, announced a year-long leave of absence and took a job as an officer with the Erving Police Department.
Community donations, meanwhile, helped fund the K-9 program that was expected to be cut.
In light of declining fuel prices, four cruisers returned to the road in the fall, and in late October, Police Chief Haigh said he still did not intend to lay off anyone. He did note, however, that he was expecting two retirements.
“If we have any supervisors that retire,” Haigh had said, “I’m not going to be able to replace them.”
— Mary Byrne
Following months of anticipation, Greenfield broke ground this year on the new fire station on Main Street, near Coombs Avenue.
The November groundbreaking ceremony came on the heels of the start of construction on the new library, which has been underway since late last year. The new library, which is being built on the parcel of land previously occupied by the former fire station, is expected to be completed in spring 2023.
Progress at the library continues forward, with masonry completed and work beginning on the exterior siding, according to the latest newsletter update from P-Three Inc., the consulting company overseeing the project.
Despite hardware and material delays, Owner’s Project Manager Daniel Pallotta has emphasized that construction is still on time and on budget.
Meanwhile, preliminary excavation work began at the new fire station lot. The groundbreaking ceremony in November followed several months of city officials figuring out a solution to cover a $2.75 million shortfall, which came in the form of a $1.75 million appropriation by City Council, $500,000 in borrowing and $500,000 in ARPA funding.
Officials anticipate the new fire station to be completed by the end of 2023.
— Mary Byrne
The July release of the Special Commission on Rural School Districts’ report shed light on the numerous and sometimes unique difficulties rural districts in Franklin, Hampshire and Berkshire counties are facing.
Co-chaired by then-state Sen. Adam Hinds, D-Pittsfield, and Rep. Natalie Blais, D-Deerfield, the report showed how declining enrollment, increasing transportation costs, and School Choice and Rural School Aid funding formulas are plaguing small, rural school districts. Local superintendents shared their stories with the Greenfield Recorder throughout the summer regarding how they try to make the most of every dollar they spend.
With the report in hand, Blais said the Legislature is “developing an omnibus bill that will include as many of the 36 recommendations included in the report as we can.” The bill will be introduced in the next session.
“While the Legislature considers these policy changes, we will also be talking with the Healey-Driscoll administration to request their support for several budget recommendations, including a significant increase to Rural School Aid,” Blais wrote in a text.
— Chris Larabee
