Tired of me blathering about a political issue a while ago, someone turned away and said over his shoulder, “Well, you’re either with us or you’re against us.” And I said to his back, “But that’s just it. Who’s us?”

People form groups based on shared ideals, kinship, community, or all sorts of things. And yes, people in a town will have their differences, but when the tornado hits or the waters rise, they help each other, working together against common perils.

So, little words like “us” can carry big meanings. Before the Civil War, citizens commonly referred to “these” United States. After that war, it was “the” United States; no longer separate states agreeing to get along, but one nation of us. “We,” “they,” “us,” “them,” “our,” “their,” so common and small we hardly give them a second thought. But we should. They define groups. Increasingly such words define friends and enemies.

The original Declaration of Independence is addressed directly to the “King of Great Britain.” He was the “He” heading a list of grievances. Gary Bourbeau’s very interesting update of that document in this space [July 6] is less specific. It is not as clear about who is meant by “We” and “They.”

In Bourbeau’s Declaration, the group of “WE … citizens of America” honors the Constitution, but not the government it defines. The offending group, “They,” apparently includes elites, academics, journalists, civil rights protesters, the Supreme Court, the House of Representatives, and the Executive Branch of government (for health-related restrictions). The Senate is elite and mis-directs taxes. Public school teachers, parents of shooting victims, and health care workers seem to be among the “they.” The people causing grievances adds up to a pretty big bunch of citizens, of us.

The “WE” Bourbeau eloquently represents — and I do believe he speaks for many — are opting out of the larger family, the nation. If the original Declaration declared revolution, Bourbeau’s announces civil war. The first U.S. Civil War was fought, among other things, to keep people from opting out because, as Lincoln put it, “A house divided against itself cannot stand.”

Another My Turn writer, John Blasiak, [July 8], uses a different little word, “our.” First, he mischaracterizes Black Lives Matter as perpetuating “the lie that skin color is the defining feature in every human experience.” It is a mischaracterization because the message of Black Lives Matter is just what it says, that Black lives matter. Then, exemplifying the white privilege he ridicules, Blasiak writes: “Our ancestors evolved cultures that led to unprecedented health, security and freedom for their people.”

While “our” in the above quote is breathtaking for ignoring the Black experience of America, the more dangerous word is “evolved.” To say culture evolved makes it sound like nature in action, survival of the fittest. Another My Turn by Mr. Blasiak [April 14] also leans toward social Darwinism. He decries social distancing and mandatory masks as infantilizing, rather than acknowledging the common peril.

“While any death is a personal tragedy for the individual and within a community, any disease with a better than 90% survival rate isn’t an existential threat,” he writes. True, but in a country with 328 million people, a ten percent fatality rate could mean millions of deaths. Yes, our species would survive. Blasiak doesn’t bother to spell out the logical conclusion — the fittest would survive. And is that how we provide “unprecedented health and security…for the people”?

Which brings me back to “we” and “they.” The United States just wasted trillions of dollars. Because some of us were so intent on asserting independence, we could not cooperate long enough to reach the goal of lowering COVID-19 contagion to the point where those who are contagious can be identified and only those people be socially isolated. Together, we could have saved lives, not wasted trillions we spent on distancing, and gotten the economy moving again, safely. But even in the face of a common enemy, we remained a house divided.

Social status is not natural law but human decisions. Humans have understanding that gives us choices. We can use knowledge, judgement, and cooperation. At our worst we don’t care about people we lump into a group that is not “ours.” At our best, we care for every person, not just “us.”

David Gilbert Keith lives in Deerfield.