“What will we leave to our grandchildren? Only when the last tree has died and the last river has been poisoned and the last fish has been caught will we realize that we cannot eat money.” — Chief Seattle circa 1960
We may, as a culture, be lulled into the notion that “change is inevitable.” Do we have a role in shaping the direction of that change? Certainly, corporations rely on the likelihood that common folks assume that “there is nothing we can do” when national chain stores propose to build in our community.
This is simply not true. I believe we have the responsibility to consider carefully the “mission statement” of the town of Deerfield.
Article 1 of the Deerfield Zoning bylaws states “These regulations are enacted to promote the general welfare of the Town of Deerfield, to protect the health and safety of its inhabitants, to encourage the most appropriate use of land throughout the town, to preserve the cultural, historical and agricultural heritage of the community … ”
Our cultural, historical and agricultural heritage is significant. We have — in another phrase from Chief Seattle — borrowed the land from our children. We might have taken our tree-lined Route 5 for granted until those trees were cut last April. Many people spoke of grief at the loss of a swath of beauty-providing, oxygen-giving mature maples and oaks which brightened the north-south drive between Sunderland and Greenfield. The saplings recently planted are a bit of a consolation, but just barely. Obviously, larger trees take up more water and sequester more carbon, while providing fall foliage fireworks displays that bring tourists from around the world.
The website www.discovernewengland.org lists Deerfield as a place where you can find “whole streets and towns that look unchanged for centuries.” According to Wikipedia, our town is “a center of heritage tourism in the Pioneer Valley.” Historic Deerfield is designated as a National Historic Landmark district.”
On a recent Saturday afternoon, I spoke to folks from across the country and around the world who traveled to Deerfield to visit the Pocumtuck Valley Memorial Association and Historic Deerfield Inc. museums and historic homes.
We are an agricultural community. The fertile soils in Deerfield and surrounding towns are the reason pioneers settled here. Small-scale farming is a risky enterprise, subject to the whims of weather and the moods of the market. Veteran farmer Wally Hibbard once told me that he was going to have to plow under his carrot crop; Stop & Shop had contracted with him, but changed tactics and switched to a huge supplier in Canada. Too late to find a similar market, he couldn’t afford to harvest his fields.
I researched the status of farming as my first project as an intern at the Pioneer Valley Planning Commission in 1987. At that time, farms were rapidly being developed into housing throughout the Valley. Since then, we have seen a resurgence of young farmers who are laying it all on the line to live their values. Behind the counter at the Atlas Farmstand, diagonally across the road from the proposed Dollar General site, their credo reads: “We strive to be a model of ecological food production, and to minimize our resource consumption and environmental impact with constant improvements to our farm. We are proud to be a part of the rich agricultural heritage of the valley…”
We will not get this commitment to our public health and to the planet from national box stores.
Many organizations have devoted resources to preserving both the agricultural land and the farming profession. The Community Involved in Supporting Agriculture (CISA) just celebrated its 25th anniversary. In its most recent annual report, CISA lists that 180 farms and businesses received technical assistance in 2017. The group’s “Be a local hero — Buy Locally Grown” campaign, launched in 1999 has raised the awareness of consumers and institutions, helping many farms with marketing strategies that allow them to operate in the black. CISA folks recently shared editorials about the need for attention to the Farm Bill, and to the success of local farms that are using their harvest to create value-added products like pickles, salsa and sriracha.
Many of these farmers have taken advantage of the Franklin County Community Development’s Western Mass Food Processing Center, whose mission is to promote economic development through entrepreneurship, provide opportunities for sustaining local agriculture, and promote best practices for food producers. Shoppers can find these products on the shelves at Ciesluk’s and Atlas, but not at a national chain store. In many communities, small retailers have been forced to close after the intrusion of national discount chains who purchase trailer loads of goods made around the globe.
Deerfield is just one of the 1,000 new stores Dollar General plans to open this year; for more details, read the NPR story aired on Dec. 11, 2017, “How Dollar General is Transforming Rural America.”
The Franklin Land Trust is active in Deerfield assisting in completed state agricultural preservation restrictions (state APRs) on many of the farms in this region. To date, we have helped conserve over 2073 acres of land in Deerfield through 55 projects with over 30 of these projects being farm conservation initiatives. Constructing a national chain diminishes the value of the hard work and dollars that have been invested in local agriculture.
According to Rolling Stone, family farmers are currently experiencing the worst economic downturn since the 1980s. At the 33rd Farm Aid concert in Hartford CT this past September, Neil Young pleaded with the crowd to go to farmer’s markets, and “stay away from those dollar stores.” He was delivering this message based on the harmful effects dollar stores are having on local farm economies across the country. In this past year, we have three proposals for new construction of Dollar General stores — Deerfield, Cummington and Bernardston.
The corporation won’t stop until the region is saturated — Vermont has 31 Dollar General stores, including ones in the smallest, most rural towns.
Culturally, we are blessed with many small retailers. Naturally, when stocking their shelves with locally grown and manufactured goods, these stores cannot match the “discount prices” of national chain stores. You can, however, talk directly to the owners, make special requests, ask about the source of products, and support your neighbors directly, circulating money within our region.
In five years, Deerfield will celebrate its 350th anniversary. We cannot take our heritage for granted. We have a legacy to pass to future generations. If we do not support the individuals and organizations who have, for centuries, kept our agricultural, cultural, and historic riches solvent, we will forever lose these resources. We will have defaulted on our children’s loan. Our region will gradually become criss-crossed with strip malls.
Route 5 in Deerfield will look like “any town” USA. What will Deerfield look like in 2023, on its 350th birthday? When they ask how decisions were made, will you have an explanation for your great-grandchildren?
Laurie Boosahda lives in South Deerfield.
