ORANGE — The Orange Economic Development and Industrial Corporation (OEDIC), leading a presentation before about 50 people at Town Hall last week, shared information on its top priority: the future of the former Butterfield School.
Those in attendance gathered in the Ruth B. Smith Auditorium to hear a pair of presentations — one by OEDIC and one by the Massachusetts Housing Partnership — about the reuse, redevelopment and revitalization of the 2.21 acres at 94 South Main St.
Housing is a possibility for reuse of the former school, which closed in 2015 due to declining enrollment and the town’s financial issues. Non-housing options include a senior center, but feasibility has not yet been determined. The most prominent potential reuse is housing, as OEDIC Chair Tom Sexton said there is a great deal of state grant money available for that purpose, but less money for municipal services like a senior center.
According to the OEDIC’s presentation, the school was built for $14,000 in 1878. It originally served as Orange High School until 1957, when it became an elementary school. OEDIC Vice Chair Christopher Woodcock got choked up as he explained that his father and uncle graduated from the high school in 1942 and 1949, respectively. He mentioned that he and his brothers attended Butterfield.
“Through all of that time, it was a really terrific school with terrific teachers,” he said.
A 2023 feasibility study by SSV Architects deemed the roughly 37,500-square-foot building to be structurally sound. The only major identified concerns were asbestos in the old furnace and a lack of accessibility for people with disabilities. The study also identified housing (apartments or senior housing) as the most viable of three potential reuses, which include a senior center and municipal offices. OEDIC assumed ownership of the site following a vote at the 2025 Annual Town Meeting.
The local development organization believes housing is the best fit for the property and the best opportunity to secure project funding. A housing shortage means limited available and affordable units for sale or rent, and housing stock decreased by 6% between 2012 and 2022, according to the 2025 Existing Conditions Report, an addendum to Grow Orange 2035, which is the town’s long-range comprehensive plan. Redevelopment could include market-rate and/or affordable mixed-income housing for seniors, individuals and families.
MassDevelopment awarded $200,000 in grant funding to OEDIC in October 2026 to support the redevelopment of the former school. The money was provided through the state’s Community One Stop for Growth initiative and consists of two separate $100,000 grants. One of the grants will enable OEDIC to undertake a Phase II Environmental Site Assessment to determine if hazardous substances, petroleum products or other environmental contaminants are present in the property’s soil or groundwater. The other can be used to advance the redevelopment effort through pre-construction feasibility, planning and design work.
At last week’s meeting, Woodcock highlighted four case studies from across the state in which former school buildings were converted to housing — Residences at the Park in Athol, Baldwinville School Apartments in Templeton, Adams Memorial School in Adams and Sitkowski School Apartments in Webster. He said these are examples of the types of models that OEDIC has in mind.
Christine Madore, director of community assistance at the Massachusetts Housing Partnership, spoke remotely about housing trends in Orange. MHP is an affordable housing nonprofit that works with the governor and the Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities to increase affordable housing in the state.
Madore explained that housing is considered “affordable” when rent or mortgage, plus utilities, is no more than 30% of a household’s gross income. She said that under “affordable rent,” tenants pay 25% to 30% of their actual income for housing expenses (rent and utilities); their share of rent is adjusted if their incomes rise; and the government pays the rest of the rent, up to a specified contract amount.
Some positives of reusing former school buildings for housing, Madore said, include existing infrastructure and utilities to support more density and historic tax credits; classroom floor plans and wide corridors that are often conducive to housing; a public request-for-proposals process that enables a town to determine redevelopment goals and select the best developer; and bringing vacant buildings back onto the tax rolls.
She acknowledged that some negative aspects include development costs, and potential zoning changes and variances.
Sexton said in an interview that senior housing “would make a ton of sense.”
“Everyone accepts that housing will be a core component,” he said. “The demand is obviously there.”
Sexton said OEDIC hopes to sell to a developer by the middle of next year.
An online survey has been posted to the OEDIC website. It can be found at tinyurl.com/ButterfieldProjectSurvey.
