ERVING — After airing concerns about the potential impact to school finances and local control over future development under a proposed Mill Overlay District zoning bylaw, voters ultimately approved all three articles presented at Monday’s Special Town Meeting.

It was close to standing-room only for the 45 voters and town officials who gathered at the Erving Senior & Community Center. After electing temporary Moderator Linda Downs-Bembury and testing the clicker system for voting, voters swiftly approved Articles 1 and 2.

Balancing development and local impact

The largest portion of the meeting was dedicated to voting on zoning bylaw changes brought forward by the Planning Board. The vote was structured in two motions, with Motion A designated for passing all zoning amendments that require a simple majority, while Motion B encompassed amendments requiring a two-thirds majority vote.

Covered under Motion A was the creation of a Mill Overlay District.

The overlay district would regulate the redevelopment of properties along the Millers River at parcels on Papermill Road, River Street, East Main Street and Arch Street. The overlay is intended to give the existing mill facilities options for mixed-use development and allow for expanded housing options in Erving. Existing zoning regulations for these parcels, under the Central Village, Village Residential and Rural Residential zones, allow for certain residential, business and industrial uses, either by right or through a special permit.

Mark Burnett, a sixth grade teacher at Erving Elementary School, spoke against passing Motion A of Article 3, due to concerns about the Mill Overlay District. In making his argument, Burnett brought up a March 2022 Special Town Meeting zoning article that would have created a Planned Unit Development overlay district, if an amendment removing that language from consideration hadn’t been passed.

Burnett said the concern raised at the time was about the potential impact that housing development plans put forward at the International Paper Mill would have on Erving’s budget during a time when Erving Elementary School was struggling financially. Burnett said his concern was that the same kind of plans from 2021 would be presented again, clarifying later that his worry less so centered on the idea of adding housing in Erving, but more on drawing town resources away from the school or adding to residents’ tax burden.

“I think it also leaves a lot of authority with just a few people on the Planning Board, whomever they may be,” Burnett said. “But I like the idea that this is very clear that the voters all have a say on this, and that we do it here tonight.”

The 2021 development proposal Burnett was referencing was a two-phase plan from The Community Builders for converting the former International Paper Mill into 60 mixed-income housing units, with a new building for possible senior housing and commercial use. This plan, and another from Rural Development Inc., came to the town in December 2021 after a Request for Interest period allowed developers to express interest in the 8 Papermill Road property and did not involve formal redevelopment proposals, which town officials clarified during Monday’s meeting. For The Community Builders’ plan to work, creation of the Planned Unit Development district would have needed to be approved by voters.

Planning Board Chair Debra Smith explained that under current zoning bylaws in Erving, multi-unit housing is allowed within the mill districts through a special permit process, but the biggest change would be allowing for mixed-use development. The zoning change could increase developer interest, which, in turn, could benefit Erving’s tax base. She also spoke to how the overlay district would limit the extent of housing allowed in a proposal as a way of supporting multi-use projects.

“This [Mill Overlay District] actually gives the community safeguards. It doesn’t take everything away. We’re trying our best to keep it to existing footprints. We’re limiting housing to 50%,” Smith said, “so this actually gives the town safeguards.”

Former Planning Board Chair and current Selectboard member Jacquelyn Boyden spoke about Northampton and Ludlow, and their redevelopment of old mill buildings, while also emphasizing the need for housing options in Erving.

Burnett pushed back to say Erving isn’t like either of those communities and that the same plans presented four years ago will come back again.

“Sometimes you have to take a chance, and then you have to stay involved. If this [Mill Overlay District] passes, and we do get a developer for the mills, that’s when your public input is important,” Boyden said, adding that the overlay district’s creation gives direction to developers about the desires of the town.

By the end of the discussion, Motion A passed with the required simple majority with 26 “yes” votes, 12 “no” votes and two abstentions, thus green-lighting the creation of the Mill Overlay District.

Motion B, which dealt with the uses section of the Mill Overlay District, inspired significantly less discussion. Responding to one question, Smith said there will be no data centers allowed to be built in Erving in any district as part of these zoning bylaws. She stated that the Planning Board feels data centers aren’t a good fit for Erving.

Motion B passed with its necessary two-thirds majority, receiving 28 “yes” votes and 12 “no” votes.

Other articles

Article 1 dealt with outstanding bills from the prior fiscal year totaling $4,504, to be funded from a variety of sources. Article 2 came at the request of the Massachusetts School Building Authority, seeking voter approval to transfer a previously appropriated $200,000 from the Capital Stabilization Fund to the Capital Project Fund for the schematic design portion of Erving Elementary School’s roof and heat pump replacement project.

Neither Article 1 or Article 2 prompted any questions or debate from voters.

A full recording of Erving’s Special Town Meeting is available at tinyurl.com/4cc6d2bw.

Erin-Leigh Hoffman is the Montague, Gill, and Erving beat reporter. She joined the Recorder in June 2024 after graduating from Marist College. She can be reached at ehoffman@recorder.com, or 413-930-4231.